Evaluate By the Comfort Design Air Conditioning & Heating team · Updated November 5, 2026
Quick answer
A good replacement quote lists the equipment's tonnage, SEER2 (and HSPF2 for heat pumps), matched indoor and outdoor units, the plan for ductwork, thermostat and old equipment removal, permits, and warranty paperwork. Reviewing these line items helps you compare options and understand the installation process.
Understanding Cooling Capacity and Sizing
Look for the tonnage and how the size was chosen.
- Cooling capacity is sold in tons, where one ton equals 12,000 Btu per hour of heat removal.
- The quote should list the exact tonnage proposed for your Coastal Bend home.
- Ask if the tonnage came from an ACCA Manual J room-by-room load calculation.
- An oversized system can reach the set temperature before it removes much moisture.
- This leaves the home cool but clammy, making accurate sizing very important.
Checking the Efficiency Ratings on Your Quote
Your quote will list efficiency ratings based on the updated testing standards implemented by the U.S. Department of Energy.
- Since January 1, 2023, the U.S. Department of Energy measures efficiency with the SEER2 standard.
- Your proposal should clearly display this rating for the proposed cooling equipment.
- HSPF2 is the matching heating-efficiency rating for heat pumps under the same 2023 test.
- A standalone air conditioner will only list a SEER2 rating, as it does not provide heating.
Identifying the Equipment and Installation Details
A thorough quote specifies exactly what equipment is being installed and what happens to your existing setup.
- Look for confirmation that you are getting matched indoor and outdoor units.
- The proposal should state what happens to your existing ductwork during the project.
- Check if a new thermostat is included or if your current one will remain in place.
- The quote should clearly state the process for the removal of your old equipment.
Reviewing Permits and Manufacturer Paperwork
Administrative details like permits and manufacturer documentation are part of a complete replacement quote.
- Look for a line item detailing who pulls the required local building permits.
- A complete quote outlines the responsibility for handling these administrative tasks.
- Check if the proposal includes the manufacturer warranty terms for the new equipment.
- Ask who is responsible for filing the manufacturer warranty paperwork after installation.
- Having these administrative steps written directly in the quote keeps responsibilities clear.
Questions to Ask When Comparing Quotes
When reviewing multiple proposals, ask specific questions to understand the differences in the offered options.
- Ask why one proposal suggests a different tonnage than the other for your home.
- Compare whether the manufacturer warranty terms vary between the offered equipment.
- See if the timeline for pulling permits differs between the two proposals.
- Ask how long the installation crew expects the entire replacement process to take.
- Question who will be your main point of contact during the installation day.
Common questions
What is an ACCA Manual J calculation?
ACCA Manual J is the industry method for calculating a home's heating and cooling load room by room from its size, insulation, windows, orientation, air leakage, and local climate.
Can I compare old SEER and new SEER2 ratings?
Compare SEER2 to SEER2; a SEER2 number reads a little lower than an old SEER number for the same equipment.
How do contractors select equipment and design ducts?
Installers use ACCA Manual S to select the equipment based on the room-by-room load calculation. They use ACCA Manual D to design the ducts to support the new air conditioner or heat pump.
Why did the Department of Energy update to SEER2?
The updated testing standard uses higher airflow resistance closer to real ductwork. This change creates conditions that better reflect how the equipment will actually operate in a typical home environment.
